Poll: Tony Chachere’s or Slap Ya Mama


I had a very surreal moment last month. Trying to find something at Trader Joe’s, I overheard a man with a British accent asking a store employee if TJ’s carried something called Tony Shasheer’s.

“Excuse me?” the store employee said.

“Tony Shusheery’s?” the Brit said.

“Say what now?” the employee responded.

“It’s a Louisiana seasoning blend,” the Brit said.

“No,” the employee said.

I should take a moment to point out that, defying centuries of Wheaton genetic coding, I didn’t insert myself into this conversation. One, the first rule of Trader Joe’s is “Get the hell out of Trader Joes.” Two, I knew that TJ’s didn’t have Tony Chachere’s.

If you’re not from Louisiana, allow me to explain. Tony Chachere’s is a seasoning blend, a magical little canister of dust to spice up your food. Use it for cooking. Use it on your eggs. Use it for crawfish and crab boils. For those of you from the Eastern Atlantic coast, you should think along the lines of Old Bay. Except Tony Chachere’s doesn’t taste like a dusty sack of stale spices.

SEE ALSO: Talkin’ Funny Louisiana Style and More Talkin’ Funny Louisiana Style

Another thing that happened in the last month or so was that I came across a line of Slap Ya Mama products at a World Market here in Brooklyn.


Slap Ya Mama is similar to Tony Chachere’s. Unlike Tony’s, it’s a lot easier for the uninitiated to pronounce. Slap Ya Mama loyalists say it’s better than Tony’s because it’s got less salt. (In fact, Slap Ya Mama was created because someone wanted a seasoning blend with less salt.)

I’m afraid to wade into this particular fight.

Tony’s is made in Opelousas, which is where I’m from. I grew up with Tony’s (I also went to school with Tony’s grandkids). I traveled with Tony’s. I tried to teach New Yorkers for decades how to pronounce Tony Chachere’s (phonetic attemp: sa-sher-ee). Before Frank’s hot sauce came up with the brilliant tag line, “I put that shit on everything,” people from Louisiana put that shit on everything.

Slap Ya Mama is made in Ville Platte, where a lot of my mama’s people live.

In fact, funny little story. My very first news story for Advertising Age (something they thought was a risk since I was just a copy editor) was about Chile Pepper Magazine and the zesty food movement. Slap Ya Mama, made by Walker & Son’s, had been handing out samples at a Chile Pepper Event, so I called up someone at Slap Ya Mama and the inevitable happened. The woman said, “We’re from a small town you probably never heard of,” and I was all, “Honh, honh, honh. Au contraire, ma cher! I got people there!” And she said, “Who?” And I said, “Dis one, dat one and da other one.” And she said, “Mais, I know them!” And then she sent me a case of Slap Ya Mama.

I also have a cousin who works at Slap Ya Mama.

Truth is, I don’t use either one of them that much, unless I’m boiling crabs or crawfish. When it comes to other cooking, I prefer to control the spices myself and more often than not, I’m sticking to salt and black pepper.

That said, I’m curious, for any Louisiana fans reading this. What’s your poison?

14 thoughts on “Poll: Tony Chachere’s or Slap Ya Mama

  1. Depends. I like slap ya mama better for eggs and as a topper. I like Tony’s better for actual cooking and for the top of my potato salad. I find slap ya mama to be more of a spice and Tony’s more of a seasoning, if that makes sense.

  2. I had to vote “something else”, but I did run it by you for approval before I purchased it

  3. I find Papa Gator’s seasoning to be the best blend and not so salty when you add a lit for extra heat. I really don’t like T C and find S Y M usable.

  4. I like “Mr. Grant’s” made by Grant Cannatella of Cannatella’s Grocery in Melville. Not too salty and has plenty of spice!

  5. I like tonys on my fries, that’s about it. Tonys is more of a salt substitute because it is very salty. Slap Ya Mamas is my go to supermarket cajun spice blend, whether is rice and gravy, red beans, gumbo, etouffee, etc.

  6. Can you get us the salt, black pepper, garlic, red pepper ratio for Slap Ya Mama?

  7. I’m from Mississippi & grew up on Tony’s. In my adulthood, I discovered Slap Yo Mama & have been hooked since. I definitely favor Slap Yo Mama.

  8. I’ve been using Tony’s Creole seasoning all my life. I have recently tried Slap Ya Mama and I still prefer Tony’s. I like a lot of spice but not a lot of salt and they both have too much salt.

  9. I forgot to say I was born in Beaumont but have family in both northern La in Monroe and southern La in Baton Rouge.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s